The Best and the Worst Car Insurance Companies (You Should Now!)

The Best and the Worst Car Insurance Companies(You Should Now!)

Knowing the best car insurance companies can help you to get the best plans. But knowing the worst insurance companies is also equally important.

Are you looking for car insurance? There are a lot of people, who do not go for insurance plans according to their need, but it is not at all a good idea as it will not be profitable for you in the long run.

A number of television commercials of car insurances promise forgiveness for accidents, no requirement of the deductibles, along with a number of advantages of the policy But such points will be important to you, only after you claim your insurance.

The best and the worst auto insurers

Consumer Reports had a look at the industry of car insurance, and surveyed more than 64000 reviews about the level of satisfaction, the process of claiming insurance, and the experience, a client gets.

You should look at the top 12 best and worst car insurance companies according to them.

Top 12 top car insurers

  1. USAA Property & Casualty
  2. Erie Insurance Group
  3. Ameriprise Financial (IDS)
  4. Geico
  5. Amica Insurance
  6. New Jersey Manufacturers Insurance Company
  7. Auto Club Insurance Association
  8. State Farm
  9. Mercury
  10. Auto Club Enterprises Insurance Group
  11. State Auto Insurance Companies
  12. Auto-Owners Insurance Group of Companies

The top 12 worst car insurers

  1. AAA Northern California, Nevada & Utah Insurance Exchange
  2. American Family
  3. MetLife
  4. Farmers Insurance
  5. The Progressive Group of Insurance Companies
  6. The Hartford Financial Services Group
  7. Allstate
  8. Mapfre USA
  9. Travelers
  10. Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company
  11. Liberty Mutual
  12. Hanover Insurance

Maybe you want read this:The Top 15 Vehicles Cheapest to Insure



When you are choosing car insurance, you should make sure that the deductibles are not too low. If you get car insurance with a low deductible, it will eventually trigger the premium rates very high. It can even intend you to make claims for small incidents, which will eventually leave you in trouble.

Almost nobody want to claim car insurance for trivial issues like, a broken windshield, a smashed indicator or something like that, as the process may be too long, and you might face undesired consequences.

In such cases, the insurer might impose penalty on you, or even deduct the discounts, which you deserve, and in the worst case, there can even be a black mark on your C.L.U.E. report. With a black mark on the report, you cannot go for the best insurance plans for the next 36 months.

The unknown bad sides of roadside assistance

A number of auto insurers offer numerous add-ons with your policy, which can make you think, you are getting the best features at a cheap price. But, using such add-ons could actually reduce your benefits or can even increase the premium rates.

A number of auto insurers offer the roadside assistance through a C.L.U.E. report, but that is not a great idea, as you will not need those services a lot. You might need to fix your flat tires, for which a mechanic will be more important than roadside assistance coverage

According to money expert Clark Howard, the insurers can literally take any decision through the C.L.U.E. report, and there isn’t any proper rule to be followed. Even in such circumstances, you cannot take your own decision or make an appeal.

Thus, the only rule is, you should never go for any roadside assistance from any insurer. If you are forced to take that, get the insurance from somewhere else.

You should shop around, and that is the best way to get low rates.

If you think, you are spending too much for auto insurance; you should look for other insurers. Here is the way to start the process.

Start finding the insurers

Clark has talked about the advantages of Amica Mutual and USAA long ago. But, apart from the two insurers, there are a number of other auto insurers, you can look for You should better look at the list of the best auto insurers in the market, and find out the best ones, which will fulfill all your requirements.

Getting the quotes

Once you find out all the insurers, who have the ability to fulfill all your needs, you should start getting the quotes. It will hardly take 10 or 15 minutes to call every insurer and get the best quotes. You should keep the existing policy papers in front of you to know your vehicle model and similar other aspects.

You can also start talking with an insurance broker. The insurance broker will come with a number of quotes for you, and all the quotes will come from the insurers, the broker has tie-up with. If you are having short time, talking to a broker is a great idea to get your insurance quote.

Comparing quotes

Once you get all the quotes, it is the time; you should compare all of them. You should compare them, by considering, all of them provide the same amount of coverage. If a poorly rated company is offering you insurance at a great price, it is better that you avoid it. It might ask for low premiums, but you can face numerous hassles later on.

Other facts to know about comp and collision

The basic rule about comp and collision is that, if the cost of the premium is more than 10% of the value of your old vehicle, you should find out a new insurance policy. If you do not know the value of your vehicle, you can find it at Edmunds.com, NADA.com, or even KBB.com.

An example will make it easier to understand. Let your vehicle worth be $4000. In case you are paying a value more than $400 on an annual basis, it does not make any financial sense. But, in case you cannot find a better option, you should go with paying for the service of comp and collision.

Be prepared for a high deductable

You should go for $1000 deductible for the best possible savings with your policy. It can help you to pay low premium rates, and will not insist you to make any small claims.

Remember the discounts.

There are numerous ways to get discounts on car insurances. Here are a few ways for it.

  • College students living elsewhere
  • Customer for numerous years
  • Numerous policies with a company
  • No accident for few years
  • Devices for antitheft
  • Some driver courses
  • Low yearly mileage
  • No traffic violence’s
  • More than a single car